In the quiet town of East Haddam, Connecticut, a chilling mystery has left residents and authorities perplexed for decades. Robert “Bob” Kalosky, a local resident, has experienced the tragic and suspicious deaths of two wives nearly two decades apart, both occurring under eerily similar circumstances in the same residence.
The first incident dates back to February 1999, when Bob’s wife, Paula Kalosky, was discovered dead from a gunshot wound to the head in their home. At the time, the death was ruled a suicide, and no charges were filed. However, the case remained a topic of quiet speculation within the community.
Fast forward to March 2018, and tragedy struck again. Bob’s second wife, Sandra Kalosky, was found dead in the same house, having suffered blunt force injuries to her head and upper extremities. This time, the medical examiner ruled her death a homicide. Despite the ruling, no arrests have been made, and authorities have not publicly identified any suspects or persons of interest. The case remains unsolved, leaving the community in a state of unease.
The striking similarities between the two deaths have raised numerous questions. Both women died under suspicious circumstances in the same residence, nearly 19 years apart. The lack of resolution in Sandra’s case has been particularly troubling for her family and friends, who continue to seek justice.
In October 2019, a federal court judge ruled that Zurich American Life Insurance Company was not obligated to pay out Sandra Kalosky’s $257,000 life insurance policy to Bob Kalosky. Judge Victor Bolden ordered the insurance benefit to be placed into an escrow account, citing the unresolved nature of the homicide as a complicating factor.
The ongoing investigation into Sandra’s death has been marked by a lack of publicly available information. Authorities have stated that the case remains active, but have provided few details, leading to frustration among those seeking answers.
The Kalosky case serves as a haunting reminder of the complexities and challenges inherent in homicide investigations, especially when multiple suspicious deaths occur within the same family. As time passes, the community of East Haddam continues to hope for a breakthrough that will bring clarity and justice to the mysterious deaths of Paula and Sandra Kalosky.
